Trump Seeks Dismissal Of N.Y. Civil Fraud Case
The request aligns with Trump's appeal against a substantial civil fraud judgment demanding he pay $454 million, currently under review by a New York appeals court. Sauer argues that, like several previous legal challenges Trump faced, this one also lacks a solid foundation and thus, should be dismissed.
Legal Pleas Point to National Interests
In his communication with the Attorney General's office, Sauer cited recent legal dismissals, including actions dropped by special counsel Jack Smith and decisions by U.S. District Judge Tanya Chutkan and Judge Juan Merchan in separate matters. These precedents bolster the argument for dismissing the current case to prevent negative impacts on national unity and business climate.
Sauer emphasized the absence of any actual victims or financial losses resulting from Trump's actions, challenging the basis of the fraud claims. He insisted that Trump's business dealings were not only transparent but also beneficial to all parties involved.
Highlighting the procedural fairness, Sauer noted that all financial obligations under Trump were met promptly, often ahead of schedule, contributing positively to New York's economic landscape and his partners' profitability.
Impact on New York's Business Environment
According to Sauer, the ongoing litigation poses a significant threat to the business environment in New York, driving entities to consider relocation to states with more favorable legal conditions. This, he claims, is contrary to the public interest and detrimental to the state’s economic health.
Trump's contributions to New York are notable, including projects like the Wollman Rink restoration and developments at the West Side Railyards and the Jacob Javits Center, which have spurred local development and job creation.
The legal challenge, if continued, could undermine these contributions and the overall business climate in New York, argued Sauer.
A Historical Call for Unity
Invoking President Abraham Lincoln's legacy, Sauer drew parallels between Lincoln's efforts during the Civil War and the current political climate. He quoted Lincoln's calls for national healing, suggesting that dismissing the lawsuit against Trump could similarly help bridge the nation’s current divides.
"President Trump has called for our Nation's partisan strife to end, and for the contending factions to join forces for the greater good of the country," Sauer stated, framing the legal battles Trump faced as distractions from more pressing national concerns.
Sauer's letter to James expressed a hopeful tone, urging the Attorney General to seize the opportunity to promote unity and healing by dismissing the charges, echoing Lincoln's reconciliation efforts during one of America's most tumultuous periods.
Conclusion of Legal Request
"In furtherance of our conversations with your office, we write to request that you completely dismiss the above-referenced case against President Donald J. Trump, his family, and his businesses, and stipulate to vacate the Judgment and dismiss all claims with prejudice," concluded Sauer in his plea to Attorney General James.
The formal request highlights a strategic shift in Trump’s legal defense, positioning the lawsuit’s dismissal as a step toward national healing rather than merely a legal victory.
This significant legal maneuver comes at a pivotal time as Trump transitions from a contentious election season to preparing for his presidency, where he will undoubtedly face continued scrutiny and challenges.