Harris Previously Supported Slavery Reparations Bill, But Stays Mum on Topic Amid Presidential Campaign
Vice President Kamala Harris, once a vocal advocate for studying slavery reparations, has noticeably avoided the topic during her current presidential campaign.
As a senator, Harris backed legislation to examine reparations proposals, a position that seems to stand in contrast with her current silence on the issue amid her White House bid, as The Hill reports.
Introduction of H.R. 40 and Harris' Early Support
In 2019, then-California Sen. Kamala Harris supported a significant legislative effort related to America's history of slavery—the introduction of a Senate companion to House Resolution 40 (H.R. 40).
This bill aimed to establish a federal commission tasked with examining the enduring impacts of slavery and proposing reparative actions.
First proposed by Rep. John Conyers Jr. in 1989, H.R. 40 has been a recurring subject in Congress, reflecting persistent interest and controversy over reparations. Upon Conyers' death, the late Rep. Sheila Jackson Lee took up the mantle to push the bill forward.
Despite numerous introductions, it was not until April 14, 2021, that H.R. 40 reached a floor vote, marking a historic moment in the long legislative journey of reparations advocacy.
Details of the Legislation and Public Opinion
The core of H.R. 40 revolves around creating a commission to thoroughly assess the long-term effects of slavery and ongoing discriminatory practices against African Americans. The commission's goal would be to recommend ways to rectify these historical and contemporary injustices through reparative measures.
Public sentiment on reparations varies widely, with a stark divide along racial lines. While 77% of Black Americans support some form of reparations, only 18% of white Americans share this view, illustrating a significant racial gap in attitudes toward this policy.
The increased momentum for reparations, particularly after the 2020 police involved murder of George Floyd, has led to more widespread discussions and even some local actions like task forces in California and Chicago exploring reparative measures.
Harris and National Leaders on Reparations
During her Senate tenure, Harris was an active supporter of the reparations study bill, emphasizing the need to understand and address the consequences of "generations of discrimination and institutional racism," as she stated in a 2019 NPR interview.
By way of contrast, former President Donald Trump has expressed skepticism about the feasibility of reparations, casting doubt on the chances of federal action on the subject during his administration. Meanwhile, President Biden has shown openness to studying the reparations issue, albeit emphasizing immediate actions to tackle systemic racism without waiting for study results.
This contrast in approaches highlights the varied political perspectives on how the United States should confront and potentially compensate for its historical legacies of racial injustice.
The Future of Reparations Legislation
In the wake of Jackson Lee's death in July, the future of H.R. 40 and reparations legislation faces uncertainty. She had been a passionate advocate for the bill, describing slavery as "America's original sin" that the nation has yet to fully atone for.
Sen. Cory Booker of New Jersey took up the Senate version of the bill in 2021, securing support from 19 Democratic co-sponsors and one independent, reflecting continued legislative interest in addressing reparations at the federal level.
However, the legislative path forward remains unclear, with fluctuating support and a complex national discourse on race and historical accountability.
Broader Implications and Vice President's Current Stance
The broader implications of reparations touch on deep-seated issues of racial inequality and justice in America. As vice president, Harris has refrained from publicly addressing reparations, a notable shift from her previous stance. This silence raises questions about the role of reparations discourse in her presidential campaign strategies.
Jasmine Harris, commenting on the VP's broader approach to racial justice, emphasizes a focus on creating equal opportunities for all Americans, suggesting a shift towards more general equity measures rather than specific reparations proposals.
As the political landscape evolves, the reparations debate continues to provoke thought, discussion, and varying levels of governmental response, reflecting its complexity and deep roots in American history and society.