DON'T WAIT.

We publish the objective news, period. If you want the facts, then sign up below and join our movement for objective news:

TOP STORIES

Latest News

Judge Aileen Cannon's Decision in Trump Case Could Influence Hunter Biden's Fate

 July 16, 2024

In a significant legal development, Judge Aileen Cannon has dismissed former President Donald Trump's classified documents case, citing the improper appointment of special counsel Jack Smith.

Cannon's ruling has spurred speculation that it might also lead to the dismissal of Hunter Biden's federal gun charges due to similar appointment issues, as Newsweek reports.

Judge Cannon's Dismissal of Trump's Case

The dismissal came on Monday morning, shaking the political and legal landscape. The case revolved around Trump’s handling of sensitive materials that were seized from his Mar-a-Lago estate after he left the White House in January 2021.

Trump faced 40 federal charges, including obstructing the efforts to retrieve these documents. The former president, however, pleaded not guilty to all charges.

The recent turn of events unfolded shortly after the former president was injured in an assassination attempt during a rally in Pennsylvania, adding another layer of complexity to the situation.

Trump Shows Resilience

Following the dismissal, Trump enthusiastically took to his platform on Truth Social. He deemed the ruling the "first step" in terminating what he called "witch hunts" against him.

Ronny Jackson, a former White House physician and current congressman, commented on Trump’s resilience after the assassination attempt "The staff is a little shaken up, I think, but he was not fazed at all by this. He was his same usual self, and he's been in a great mood," Jackson noted.

Jackson also pointed out, "To be honest with you, I think the most traumatic thing for him was not the superficial, minor injury that he sustained, but the fact that he was in the medical tent with the gentleman who passed away."

Implications for Hunter Biden's Case

Judge Cannon's ruling has stirred speculation around Hunter Biden's legal troubles. The first son was recently convicted on three federal firearms counts and his facing an upcoming sentencing date.

MSNBC's Kyle Griffin and NewsNation's Dan Abrams suggested that Cannon's reasoning might pave the way for the dismissal of Hunter Biden's conviction as well. The roots of this speculation lie in the similarities concerning the appointment of special counsels.

The special counsel responsible for prosecuting Hunter Biden was David Weiss, who is also the U.S. Attorney for the District of Delaware. His dual role affects the interpretation of his appointment differently than that used in the case of Smith.

Justice Department and Legal Analysts Weigh In

Peter Carr, spokesperson for Smith's office, opined that Cannon’s dismissal diverges from the norms concluded by other courts regarding the attorney general’s powers to appoint special counsels. "The Justice Department has authorized the Special Counsel to appeal the court's order," Carr highlighted.

Michael McAuliffe, a former federal prosecutor, suggested that Cannon's ruling might not have a profound impact on Hunter Biden’s cases. "Cannon's decision and rationale are not binding in any way on other federal courts, including the presiding judges in the two districts where charges were brought against Hunter Biden," McAuliffe explained.

McAuliffe further emphasized Weiss's unique standing. "Further, David Weiss, the special counsel in the Hunter Biden cases continues to also serve as the U.S. Attorney for the District of Delaware; he was a U.S. attorney prior to his appointment as special counsel for the Hunter Biden matters," he remarked.

Weiss's Standing as a Senate-Confirmed Prosecutor

This distinction makes Hunter Biden’s case less vulnerable to the special counsel appointment challenge that succeeded in Trump’s documents case. McAuliffe noted, "While Cannon's dismissal order reserves formal judgment (doesn't make a finding) as to the inferior/principal officer issue, she employs basically the same analysis of factors in concluding that the special counsel regulations (or any other law) don't empower the appointment and funding of a special counsel."

Additionally, McAuliffe reiterated the importance of Weiss's status. "Because David Weiss, the special counsel in the Hunter Biden cases, also is a U.S. attorney, the distinction remains critical even if one adopts Cannon's analysis."

This turns the legal spotlight onto the complexity and nuance of Special Counsel appointments and their implications across different cases.

Conclusion

Judge Aileen Cannon’s decision to dismiss the case against former President Donald Trump has opened up discussions about the potential effects on Hunter Biden’s convictions regarding gun charges.

While some legal analysts suggest a possible ripple effect, others highlight the unique circumstances that set the two cases apart.

As the Justice Department plans to appeal Cannon’s ruling, the implications of this decision remain to be fully seen.