DON'T WAIT.

We publish the objective news, period. If you want the facts, then sign up below and join our movement for objective news:

TOP STORIES

Latest News

Kirby on Controversial Prisoner Exchange: ‘No One Is Celebrating Here’

 August 2, 2024

The largest prisoner exchange since the Cold War, involving the United States and Russia, has ignited substantial criticism and debate.

The Biden administration-engineered exchange led to release of three Americans and several political dissidents held by Russia, in return for Russian assassin Vadim Krasikov, who was freed by Germany and greeted with an embrace by President Vladimir Putin, as Fox News reports.

Government Addresses Exchange Criticism

During a widespread discussion, John Kirby, communications adviser for the White House National Security Council, tackled the criticism emerging from the latest prisoner exchange.

Kirby engaged with Bret Baier on Special Report, confronting backlash over the liberation of Krasikov. The assassin, convicted of a 2019 murder, was released by Germany and spotted embracing President Putin upon returning to Moscow. He stated the decision required significant "moral courage" from German Chancellor Olaf Scholz.

Notable Figures Released

Included in the exchange were three high-profile Americans: Former Marine Paul Whelan, Wall Street Journal reporter Evan Gershkovich, and Russian-American journalist Alsu Kurmasheva. The prisoners were welcomed back on Thursday night and reached Joint Base Andrews in Maryland.

Kirby emphasized the complex and arduous nature of negotiations with Russia, stating the importance of freeing innocent people held unjustly.

Complex Dynamics in International Negotiations

Evaluating the overall impact of the swap, Kirby pointed out that, on balance, the release of innocent individuals outweighed the controversial aspects.

Kirby commented, "In the end, when you weigh it... I think we could all agree that it's better to have innocent people no longer rotting in Russian prisons for the rest of their lives."

He further stressed the historical patterns of Russia wrongfully detaining Americans for leverage and urged U.S. citizens not to travel to Russia due to a strong detention risk.

Focus Shifts to Other Detainees

While acknowledging the significance of the recent exchange, the White House remains firm on continuing efforts to bring home other Americans wrongfully detained overseas.

This includes working towards the release of American teacher Marc Fogel, who is currently serving a 14-year sentence in a Russian penal colony for possessing medical marijuana. Kirby assured that ongoing discussions with Russian authorities are in place to facilitate Fogel's release.

No Joy in Krasikov's Release

Addressing concerns about Vadim Krasikov's freedom, Kirby clarified, "Nobody's delighted or doing backflips over here because Mr. Krasikov is now a free man."

He emphasized the need for difficult decisions in negotiations, noting, "The president was willing to make that tough call in order to get these -- all these individuals, not just the Americans -- all of them released."

Kirby reaffirmed the moral weight behind the decision and the necessity to prioritize the release of innocent detainees.

Long-term Commitment to Detainees

Kirby conveyed a longstanding commitment to securing the release of detainees. He stated, "We're going to do everything we can to get every wrongfully detained American back home or any American wrongfully detained or not that is being held overseas unlawfully."

Despite the recent successful exchange, the administration recognizes that challenges persist, particularly regarding international negotiations. Kirby's remarks highlight the ongoing and future challenges of securing freedom for those detained overseas under unjust circumstances.

Urging Caution for Russia Travel

While lauding the success of the prisoner exchange, Kirby reiterated the critical warning for Americans against traveling to Russia.

"It's not a behavior that we think is going to change anytime soon," Kirby stated, emphasizing the persistent risk of wrongful detention.

He urged citizens in Russia to consider leaving the country promptly to avoid potential detainment scenarios.

The recent swap has showcased the intricate dynamics of international diplomacy and the significant decisions needed to ensure the return of wrongfully detained citizens. The administration remains committed to these efforts, facing continued challenges as they work to bring Americans home.