DON'T WAIT.

We publish the objective news, period. If you want the facts, then sign up below and join our movement for objective news:

TOP STORIES

Latest News

Supreme Court Justice Gorsuch Highlights Risks Of Excessive Legislation

 August 11, 2024

In his latest book, "Over Ruled: The Human Toll of Too Much Law," Justice Neil Gorsuch voices concerns about the pervasive complexity of U.S. laws.

According to Fox News, the newly published work by Gorsuch sheds light on how copious legislation infringes on personal freedoms and the respect for law itself.

Co-written with Janie Nitze, Gorsuch's book, released on August 6 and quickly topping Amazon's bestseller list, explores the implications of excessive laws through personal anecdotes and examples from his extensive judicial career.

The book's direct and accessible approach reflects Gorsuch's intent to engage a wide audience, highlighting real-life stories of individuals and businesses adversely affected by dense federal regulations.

Among the narratives are those of local business owners, families, and entrepreneurs who find themselves ensnared in the complexities of regulatory compliance, including a magician whose livelihood is complicated by obscure laws.

Unexpected Laws And Their Impact On Daily Life

Gorsuch points to several obscure laws that remain in effect, such as the criminal offense of selling mattresses without proper labels or consulting with pirates. These examples illustrate the sometimes absurd reach of federal law into the minutiae of American lives.

During the COVID-19 pandemic, the expansive authority of the federal government was particularly evident when the Occupational Safety and Health Administration mandated masks, testing, or vaccines for millions under Operation Warp Speed.

These measures, according to Gorsuch, exemplify the potential overreach of federal power and its impact on personal freedoms.

Justice Gorsuch's Perspective On Legal Overreach

"I had seen many — so many — cases where the sheer volume and complexity of our laws had swallowed up ordinary people," Gorsuch remarks in his book, underscoring the overwhelming burden the legal system can impose.

He continues to reflect on the essential nature of some laws for maintaining order and protecting freedoms, yet warns, "Too much law can put those exact freedoms at risk and even undermine respect for law itself."

Gorsuch's commentary is drawn not only from his legal judgments but also from his unique vantage point within the American judicial system, offering a critique of the nation's legal framework that affects everyday citizens.

A Call For Simplicity And Fairness In Law

Despite his critical view of the current state of U.S. law, Gorsuch remains an "incorrigible optimist," believing strongly in the resilience and capability of the American people to navigate these challenges.

He advocates for a legal system that upholds the principles of fair notice, and equal treatment and promotes individual flourishing, suggesting that such a framework can restore balance and respect for the law.

Gorsuch emphasizes the need for legal reforms that simplify laws and make them more understandable and manageable for everyone, not just legal experts or those with the resources to decipher them.

Reflecting On The American Legal Landscape

"As a judge, my job is to apply the law … The best I can do is share with you what I have seen from my unusual vantage in our legal system," Gorsuch shares, highlighting the limited but crucial role he plays in addressing these systemic issues.

He also mentions a scholarly suggestion that "no one in the United States over the age of 18 can avoid indictment for some federal crime," highlighting the excessive breadth of federal criminal law.

This perspective not only critiques the current state but also calls for a reevaluation of the legal structures that govern daily activities and business operations in America.

Final Thoughts On Legal Complexity And Reform

In conclusion, Justice Neil Gorsuch's book "Over Ruled: The Human Toll of Too Much Law" serves as a poignant critique and a call to action for simplifying the U.S. legal system.

By sharing stories from various walks of life affected by the labyrinth of U.S. laws, Gorsuch highlights the urgent need for legal clarity and fairness that supports rather than encumbers the American citizenry.

His optimism about the potential for reform and his advocacy for a more just legal framework resonate as a hopeful vision for the future of American law and governance.