Obama Center Subcontractor Sues For Discrimination

 February 3, 2025

A Chicago subcontractor has launched a $40 million lawsuit against a prominent engineering firm, alleging racial discrimination.

According to Fox News, II in One claims discriminatory practices by Thornton Tomasetti led to forced extra work and financial losses.

The conflict arose during the Obama Presidential Center’s construction, a project anticipated to transform Chicago's South Side with cultural and community landmarks. The plaintiff, Robert McGee, who owns the subcontractor II in One, filed the lawsuit against New York-based Thornton Tomasetti in response to purported unfair practices on the construction site.

II in One contributed concrete and rebar services to the center, collaborating on a project envisioned to feature a museum, a library, and additional community facilities. This engagement began in 2021, following several years of planning and legal hurdles that temporarily halted construction.

Claims of Discriminatory Practices Emerge

According to McGee, racial bias played a critical role in generating excessive tasks that led to fiscal burdens for his firm. He contends that Thornton Tomasetti imposed atypical requirements related to the rebar spacing and tolerances. Such demands reportedly deviated from industry norms, resulting in significant financial overruns.

The lawsuit illustrates what McGee describes as a daunting situation for his company, portraying the structural engineer's actions as baseless criticisms and defamatory accusations. These alleged actions impacted not only the financial health of II in One but also threatened its operational viability.

Conversely, Thornton Tomasetti defends its previous guidelines, attributing issues on the project site to the subcontractor's reported lack of expertise and inefficiencies. The firm has articulated its position through memos that deny wrongdoing, emphasizing the design team’s commitment to quality and safety.

Project History and Related Challenges

The delays in construction stemmed partly from legal battles aimed at pausing or altering the development plans. Detractors raised concerns about potential neighborhood impacts, ranging from housing cost hikes to environmental damage. However, those challenges met their end in 2021 when the Supreme Court dismissed a related case.

Construction began in earnest in 2021, setting a path toward an opening expected in 2026. Despite these hurdles, the project has maintained a positive public outlook, bolstered by former President Barack Obama’s continued support. In his 2021 speech at the project's groundbreaking, Obama shared a vision of ecological revitalization along with community enhancement.

Potential Outcomes and Community Fallout

As the legal battle unfolds, what remains at stake are the reputations and financial standings of both the subcontractor and the engineering firm. At the heart of this dispute is a larger conversation about racial equality in workplace practices within the construction industry.

For the surrounding community, the Obama Presidential Center represents both a beacon of hope for family and community life and a potential catalyst for gentrification concerns. Activists keenly observe the proceedings, vigilant about future developments that might affect long-term residents.

The lawsuit and its implications will further illuminate tensions and systemic issues within the development sphere, as well as challenge institutions to reckon with claims of racial bias. The outcome of McGee's allegations may also inform broader efforts to ensure equitable treatment in large-scale urban projects.

Ultimately, the court's verdict could set a meaningful precedent regarding accountability and equity in construction practices and reinforce the transformative potential that the Obama Presidential Center promises for generations.

Amidst ongoing legal arguments and infrastructural challenges, the vision of the Obama Center stands as a symbol either awe-inspiring or contentious, depending on varied perspectives. The community, developers, and leaders await resolutions that promise conviction and clarity for the path ahead.

DON'T WAIT.

We publish the objective news, period. If you want the facts, then sign up below and join our movement for objective news:

TOP STORIES

Latest News