DON'T WAIT.

We publish the objective news, period. If you want the facts, then sign up below and join our movement for objective news:

TOP STORIES

Latest News

3 Officers Violated Protocol in Arrest of Scottie Scheffler, Investigation Finds

 June 9, 2024

Charges against golf superstar Scottie Scheffler were dismissed after findings supported his claim of a misunderstanding during his arrest on May 17 outside the Valhalla Golf Club, and the subsequent investigation highlighted failures by Louisville Metro Police officers to follow body camera protocols.

The world's No. 1 golfer, Scottie Scheffler, was arrested on May 17 near Valhalla Golf Club before the second round of the PGA Championship, and was facing four charges including felony assault, a situation which is now under heightened scrutiny due to the arresting officers' conduct, as Fox News reports.

Scheffler's arrest occurred amid an investigation into the death of John Mills, a volunteer who was struck by a shuttle bus near the golf course early that morning. The confusion surrounding Scheffler's arrest began when Louisville Metro Police Department (LMPD) officers failed to activate their body cameras during the incident.

Officers Identified in Policy Violations

Detectives Bryan Gillis, Kelvin Watkins, and Officer Javar Downs were identified as having violated LMPD policy by not following proper body camera protocols. Louisville Police Chief Jacquelyn Gwinn-Villaroel stated, "Detective Gillis should have turned on his body-worn camera but did not. His failure to do so is a violation of the LMPD policy on uniforms and equipment, subject category body-worn cameras."

Gillis claimed he was dragged by Scheffler's vehicle as Scheffler attempted to drive away. This incident led to the charges against Scheffler, which included felony assault due to the injuries sustained by the officer.

Body Camera Footage and Scheffler's Account

The arrest report indicated Scheffler was driving a PGA courtesy car when the incident occurred. Gillis’ body camera did capture some footage, including Scheffler making a phone call from jail, expressing his uncertainty about Gillis being a police officer.

Scheffler described the encounter as a "misunderstanding," a characterization that was later corroborated by Jefferson County officials. "I sat there and tried to diffuse the situation, and then I was literally reaching out trying to find a police officer, not knowing he was one. It's my fault. I mean, he's wearing a uniform. He's wearing a yellow vest. I just didn't see it," Scheffler said.

Investigation and Legal Outcomes

Jefferson County Attorney Mike O’Connell reviewed the incident and concluded there was insufficient evidence to prosecute Scheffler. "Based upon the totality of the evidence, my office cannot move forward in the prosecution of the charges filed against Mr. Scheffler. Mr. Scheffler’s characterization that this was ‘a big misunderstanding’ is corroborated by the evidence," O’Connell stated.

The investigation findings emphasized the critical role of body cameras in ensuring transparency and accountability during police encounters. Chief Gwinn-Villaroel confirmed that corrective action was taken against Detective Gillis for not adhering to the body camera protocols.

Context of the Arrest Incident

The circumstances surrounding Scheffler's arrest were further complicated by the ongoing investigation into John Mills' death. The police were actively engaged in this investigation when the incident with Scheffler unfolded, adding to the chaos and confusion.

Scheffler's arrest was initially met with significant media attention, given his high profile as the world's top-ranked golfer. The PGA Championship, one of golf's major tournaments, was the backdrop for this unexpected incident.

Clarifying Misunderstandings

Throughout the ordeal, Scheffler maintained that he did not realize Gillis was a police officer, contributing to the misunderstanding. This assertion was supported by the body camera footage, which captured Scheffler's attempts to communicate from jail.

The lack of body camera activation by the involved officers was a critical point in the investigation. This failure not only violated LMPD policy but also hindered the clear documentation of the incident, leading to questions about the actions and intentions of both parties involved.

Implications for Police Protocol

The findings of the investigation have broader implications for police protocol, particularly concerning the use of body-worn cameras. The incident highlighted the importance of adhering to established policies to prevent similar misunderstandings and ensure accountability.

The LMPD's response to the incident, including the corrective action against Detective Gillis, underscored the department's commitment to upholding these standards. This case serves as a reminder of the critical need for transparency and proper procedure in law enforcement activities.

Community and Media Response

The community and media response to Scheffler's arrest and subsequent investigation was significant. The high-profile nature of the incident drew widespread attention and scrutiny, emphasizing the need for clear communication and adherence to protocols.

Scheffler's case also highlighted the potential consequences of misunderstandings between civilians and law enforcement officers. The swift resolution and dismissal of charges against Scheffler were seen as a positive outcome, preventing a prolonged legal battle.

Conclusion

The investigation into Scottie Scheffler's arrest revealed critical failures in police protocol, particularly regarding body camera usage.

The incident, characterized by Scheffler as a misunderstanding, was corroborated by evidence reviewed by Jefferson County officials, leading to the dismissal of charges.

The case underscores the importance of adherence to established procedures in law enforcement to ensure accountability and transparency.