Trump proposes revived use of mental asylums to tackle crime, homelessness

 September 2, 2025

Amid growing concerns over crime and homelessness across major cities, President Donald Trump has proposed a controversial plan to reopen mental institutions, as the Daily Mail reports. In a recent interview, Trump delineated his approach towards reducing crime and managing homelessness by reintroducing asylums.

In a dialogue with Reagan Reese of the Daily Caller, Trump reflected on the closure of historical mental institutions, such as Creedmoor and Bellevue in New York, pointing out that these had been shut down due to budgetary constraints.

He criticized past administrations for their decision to close these facilities, which he linked to current social issues.

Exploring historical background, current needs

Trump's conversation highlighted how these institutions once played a role in states like California and New York.

He mentioned the immense financial burden of running these asylums, but emphasized their necessity in tackling issues of homelessness and crime by potentially reviving such facilities.

The president linked the increase in homelessness to the closure of these institutions, recalling a time when, following their shutdown, "they released them into society, and that's what you have now," indicating a direct correlation between the two events.

These comments emerge as part of his broader 'zero tolerance homelessness plan,' which involves multiple federal strategies.

Part of these strategies includes a hefty federal takeover of crime management in locations such as Washington, D.C., where Trump has significantly mobilized police forces and the National Guard to establish what he describes as a 'crime-free zone.'

Trump's stance on public safety, enforcement

During the crackdown in Washington, D.C., there have been over a thousand arrests. However, city officials argue that crime rates were already diminishing before these measures were implemented. This has raised questions about the efficacy and timing of Trump's aggressive policies.

Trump’s plan also involves relocating homeless populations to "beautify the city" and eradicate areas he described as "slums." He aims to clean up the aesthetics of the city while addressing what he perceives as the root causes of disorder.

Despite these promises, the plan has faced criticism from various quarters. Critics argue that many of the facilities previously closed were notorious for their harsh conditions and mistreatment of patients, raising ethical concerns over a potential revival.

Mental health debate revived

The proposal to reopen institutions has sparked a nationwide debate about the best methods to handle severe psychiatric conditions amidst rising homelessness and crime rates.

Trump responded affirmatively when asked by Reese if he would consider reopening asylums, indicating a clear intent to revisit what many consider an outdated or even repressive method of mental health care.

This initiative is part of Trump’s larger vision for America, in which he envisions a reform of the mental health system alongside stringent crime-fighting policies.

"You know, it’s massively expensive," he admitted, yet he seems resolute on revisiting these traditional methods despite the costs and historical controversies involved.

Public reactions unfold

The president's comments have fueled discussions across political and social spectrums about the implications of such measures on human rights and the effectiveness of institutionalization in addressing mental health and safety issues.

As the nation grapples with these complex issues, Trump remains steadfast in his belief that restoring asylums can play a pivotal role in his crime and homelessness strategy, often using stark language like "They spit, we hit," to emphasize his zero-tolerance policies.

The coming months are likely to further intensify these debates as Trump pushes forward with his plans, which he believes will lead to safer and cleaner communities across the United States.

DON'T WAIT.

We publish the objective news, period. If you want the facts, then sign up below and join our movement for objective news:

TOP STORIES

Latest News