Clarence Thomas warns First Amendment erodes after court snubs California bias-training case
Justice Clarence Thomas warned that First Amendment rights do not vanish under heavy state regulation after the Supreme Court refused to hear California’s forced bias-training case for doctors.
The U.S. Supreme Court on Monday declined to take up Khatibi v. Yip, a challenge to California’s rule that continuing medical education courses must include instruction on implicit bias. The denial left a Ninth Circuit ruling intact and offered no new nationwide free-speech standard. Justice Clarence Thomas, joined by Justice Samuel Alito, dissented and said lower courts are mangling the line between government speech and private speech.
Newsweek reported that the case involved physician Azadeh Khatibi and other challengers who argued the mandate compels private instructors to push the state’s preferred message. California requires licensed doctors to complete 50 hours of approved continuing medical education every two years. A 2019 state law added that qualifying patient-care courses must address implicit bias and its effects on health outcomes.
That regime survives this round at the high court. The Ninth Circuit treated the instruction inside California’s regulated CME system as government speech and rejected the First Amendment claim. Thomas said that approach gets the core question backward.
In dissent, he wrote that heavy regulation does not strip speech of constitutional protection.
"First Amendment protections do not give way simply because a State heavily regulates speech,"
Thomas stated. He argued the appeals court lost sight of whether the government is speaking for itself or regulating private expression, and he said the Court’s own multi-factor test from Shurtleff v. Boston is steering lower courts off course.
California’s CME rule forces a state message on private instructors
Under the California system, the state sets standards and may audit courses for compliance. It does not preapprove every word of every course. Private entities and instructors still organize, accredit, and teach much of the material on their own time. Challengers said forcing those instructors to address implicit bias in the state’s preferred frame is compelled speech, not the government talking with its own voice.
Fox News reported Thomas’s sharper point: when the government does not issue its own messages but requires private speakers to carry the government’s viewpoint, the First Amendment applies. He wrote that California’s requirement leaves instructors no choice but to discuss the topic in a way that affirms the state’s view that implicit bias causes disparities in health outcomes.
Pacific Legal Foundation attorney Caleb Trotter, who brought the case, called the denial a deep disappointment and warned the logic does not stop at medicine.
"Now, continuing medical education instructors teaching courses in their private capacity, on their own time, and without any review of their course by the State, have less First Amendment protection than government employees or even public school teachers when speaking in the course of their official duties."
Trotter said. He added there is little in the lower courts’ logic to limit that result to medical education, and he pledged to keep fighting attempts to require endorsement of government orthodoxy as a condition of practicing a profession.
That fight sits inside a larger fight over the Court’s direction. Democrats have kept pressure on the justices themselves, including talk of impeachment threats aimed at Supreme Court members when rulings cut against progressive priorities.
Thomas says Shurtleff is leading courts astray
Thomas’s dissent zeroed in on the government-speech doctrine. That doctrine, he noted, occupies a narrow corner of First Amendment law. The First Amendment protects the people’s speech against government interference; it does not stop the government from speaking for itself. The problem comes when courts treat regulated private speech as if it were the state’s own message.
He wrote that the Ninth Circuit’s “blinkered” use of the Shurtleff factors missed the real test: whether the government is speaking for itself or regulating private expression. In 2022’s Shurtleff v. Boston, the Court found Boston violated the First Amendment by denying a Christian group’s request to fly a flag at City Hall and held the flag program was not government speech. The framework looks at history of the expression, whom the public is likely to think is speaking, and how much the government shaped or controlled the message.
Thomas said that multi-factor approach is producing the wrong results. He had already joined Alito in a 2022 separate opinion warning that heavy regulation might be treated as converting private speech into government speech. Monday’s dissent pressed the Court to reconsider whether Shurtleff is the right mode of analysis at all.
"This Court should reconsider whether the Shurtleff test is the proper mode of analysis for identifying government speech,"
Thomas wrote. The New York Post highlighted the dissent’s blunt line that a state cannot regulate its way out of First Amendment scrutiny, and that the government-speech doctrine must not become a cover for censorship or a cloak for compelled speech.
Court-watchers also track how the justices handle other speech and religion disputes, including cases where Chief Justice Roberts has steered funding fights involving Catholic schools that keep faith-based admissions.
Three justices wanted the case; four votes were needed
The Washington Examiner noted that Thomas led the push to hear the free-speech challenge and that Justices Samuel Alito and Neil Gorsuch also would have taken the case. That left them one vote short of the four needed to grant review. The challenge was brought by California doctors, including Khatibi, and the group Do No Harm, who said the mandate forces adoption of government-approved viewpoints on race and bias.
Denial of certiorari is not a ruling on the merits. It does not bless California’s law as constitutional. It simply leaves the Ninth Circuit judgment in place for now. California’s Attorney General’s office was contacted for comment Monday morning; no response was reported in the coverage.
For the challengers, Trotter said this is the end of the road for this particular compelled-speech case. The practical result is clear: private CME instructors in California remain under a rule that treats their classroom content as government speech once the state layers on licensing, audits, and content mandates.
Similar free-speech friction shows up when courts leave disciplinary actions standing, as when the Supreme Court left a Pennsylvania judge’s suspension over partisan Facebook posts in place. The common thread is how far officials can police or script speech once a license or public role is involved.
Licensed professions become the next battleground
Thomas’s warning reaches past medicine. If heavy regulation turns private instruction into “government speech,” then any licensed field, law, nursing, teaching, counseling, could face the same move. A state could require viewpoint-based modules, call the whole system government speech, and tell objecting professionals they have no First Amendment claim.
That is the incentive problem. Progressive agencies and legislatures already push implicit-bias and related training as non-negotiable professional standards. When courts rubber-stamp those mandates as the government’s own voice, dissenters lose the ability to refuse the message without risking their livelihoods. Taxpayers and patients then get a medical education system shaped by political orthodoxy rather than open professional debate.
Democratic pressure on the Court’s size and makeup remains part of that backdrop, including calls from figures such as Hillary Clinton who have backed expanding the Supreme Court toward 13 justices. The institutional fight and the speech fight travel together.
Thomas, Alito, and Gorsuch signaled they see the California CME rule as a test case for whether the government-speech doctrine will stay narrow or become a blank check. The full Court chose not to answer that question this time. The Ninth Circuit’s approach stays on the books. Private instructors teaching on their own time still carry less protection, under that logic, than public employees speaking on the job.
First Amendment rules that protect everyone only when the state stays out of the script are the ones worth keeping, especially when a license to practice hangs in the balance.




