Marco Rubio jumps ahead of JD Vance in post-midterm 2028 GOP poll
Marco Rubio has jumped ahead of JD Vance for the first time in Emerson College’s 2028 GOP poll, a post-midterm reverse that leaves the vice president carrying administration baggage.
Newsweek reported that an Emerson College survey of 1,000 voters, fielded November 14 to 16 with a margin of error of plus or minus 3 points, found nearly 36 percent of Republicans naming Secretary of State Marco Rubio as their first choice for 2028.
Vice President JD Vance drew 20 percent. Twelve percent remained undecided. Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis stood at 7 percent, with Kentucky Rep. Thomas Massie and President Donald Trump each just under 7 percent.
The result marks Rubio’s first lead over Vance in the Emerson series and lands after Republican midterm losses. No major contender has formally entered the race, and the first primary votes remain more than a year away.
The New York Post noted the same Emerson open-ended result of 36 percent to 20 percent, while a closed-ended version of the survey put Rubio at 44 percent and Vance at 24 percent among Republican primary voters.
Earlier Emerson numbers told a different story
In February, Emerson had given Vance 52 percent to Rubio’s 20 percent, a 32-point gap. By July the race had tightened to Vance 39 percent and Rubio 38 percent. The newest survey completes the flip.
Other recent surveys still showed Vance ahead. An Echelon Insights poll of 397 likely voters, taken November 12, 16, found Vance at 40 percent, Rubio at 26 percent, and DeSantis at 12 percent. A YouGov survey of 354 registered voters, fielded November 9, 11, put Vance at 41 percent, Rubio at 34 percent, and DeSantis at 12 percent.
Prediction markets as of Thursday morning likewise kept Vance in front. Kalshi gave him a 32 percent chance at the nomination against Rubio’s 19 percent and DeSantis’s 16 percent. Polymarket showed Vance at 34 percent, Rubio 18 percent, and DeSantis 15 percent.
Just The News added that the RealClearPolitics average still gave Rubio only a narrow 1.4-point edge overall, underscoring how fluid the early field remains even after Emerson’s shift.
Strategists see voters hunting for a stronger brand
Brent Buchanan, founder and CEO of the Republican polling firm Cygnal, told Newsweek the numbers show “how unsettled the 2028 GOP primary for president is.”
"Republicans have been moving away from Trump Republicanism since the 2024 election."
Buchanan pointed to Cygnal’s midterm data claiming traditional conservative Republicans outnumbered Trump Republicans by almost 2-to-1. He argued most Republicans still support the Iran war and said Vance is “boxing himself in to appeal to the more apolitical younger voters who oppose the Iran War.”
"That's not an insignificant group because many of them stayed home in the midterm, and it cost the GOP many seats that may have withstood a blue wave but without younger centrist to right-leaning voters couldn't survive a blue tsunami."
Republican strategist Matt Klink said voters “want a winner” and are looking “for a stronger brand.”
"VP Vance carries the administration's baggage without controlling its decisions, and the polling shows the cost. Two years is a long runway, but the VP needs a story that is his own."
Klink added that Vance and Rubio “are the race for now,” while DeSantis sits far back. He also noted Rubio has said he would not run if Vance enters, so the direct matchup may never materialize.
Klink further reported that ending the war in Iran ranks as a top-two priority for 49 percent of voters, and that primary voters reward loyalty to Trump more than daylight from his policies. Rubio’s national-security résumé, he said, gives him an edge with the hawkish wing.
That résumé has already drawn notice in Rubio’s Federalist Society speech that fueled fresh White House talk.
Vance ties midterm losses to the Iran war
After the midterms, Vance posted on social media that “the reason we lost is the war,” adding that “the president himself said so last night.”
"If you'd like to argue it was worth it, that losing the Senate for the next 6 years was worth it, then do so. Argue it was a worthwhile cost to pay. Agree or disagree, that's at least honest."
In a Fox News interview he also said the United States would not allow the conflict to become a long commitment “despite the fact that a lot of neoconservatives and a lot of other people want us to stay there forever.” The article noted the war had sent gas prices soaring through disruptions in the Strait of Hormuz.
Former Vice President Mike Pence rejected the diagnosis on NBC News’ Meet the Press, calling Vance’s assessment “wrong” and stating, “We didn’t lose this midterm election because of the war.”
Fox News host Brian Kilmeade went further on his radio show, saying Vance “never should have been vice president.”
Earlier in November, President Trump announced he had asked Vance to focus on alleged crime and corruption in Democratic-led states and cities rather than take a more central role in Iran war negotiations. On Monday, Vance told Fox News’ Laura Ingraham he has not decided whether to run and will “figure it out sometime next year,” citing the infrastructure and fundraising required well before the Iowa caucuses.
Separate polling has already flagged soft spots for the vice president, including Vance’s low favorability among Jewish voters in recent surveys.
Rubio’s standing rises inside the administration
The Washington Examiner reported the same Emerson findings, placing Rubio atop early Republican preferences while Sen. Jon Ossoff led Democrats in the parallel test.
Fox News coverage highlighted the surge as well. Lara Trump discussed the early 2028 numbers on Fox & Friends First, framing Rubio as the current frontrunner among potential Republican contenders.
Rubio’s expanded portfolio inside the administration supplies part of the backdrop. Trump has already moved to make Rubio’s national security adviser role permanent with a signed commission, deepening the secretary’s foreign-policy profile.
Intra-party jockeying is already visible. Recent exchanges have included Cruz calling Vance insecure after the vice president suggested the Texas senator is already running for 2028.
Newsweek said it reached out to the offices of both Vance and Rubio for comment and received no immediate reply in the published piece. Trump remains popular with the conservative base and is barred by term limits from seeking another term.
Two years is a long runway in presidential politics. Voters who just absorbed midterm losses are already sorting winners from placeholders, and early numbers reward the candidate who looks ready to lead rather than merely inherit.




